As the 2026 AFL season looms, footy fans are finally getting a sneak peek at how all 18 clubs are shaping up—and let me tell you, it’s already full of surprises. But here’s where it gets controversial: are the Hawks truly ready to fill the void left by key departures, or are they just experimenting with a ‘committee’ approach that might backfire? Let’s dive in.
From February 16 to 21, every club will participate in unofficial match simulations, giving fans a taste of what’s to come. These games, broadcast LIVE and ad-break free on FOX FOOTY via Kayo Sports, are more than just warm-ups—they’re a chance for players to prove their mettle. New to Kayo? You can join now for just $1 and catch all the action (https://kayosports.com.au/?pg=default&extcamp=fsaeditoriallinkafl-edt-fsp-lnk-awr-grc-afl-kyo&channel=fsa&campaign=fsacontra&voucher=).
And this is the part most people miss: while the Hawks’ 17-point win over Geelong (111-94) was impressive, it’s the individual performances that are stealing the spotlight. Former top-10 draft pick Josh Ward is making a strong case for more midfield minutes, especially with Will Day injured and James Worpel gone. But here’s the twist: Hawthorn isn’t relying on a single star. Instead, they’re rotating players like Cam Mackenzie, Connor Macdonald, and Conor Nash in a ‘committee’ style. Is this a stroke of genius or a recipe for inconsistency? Only time will tell.
Macdonald, in particular, stood out with his ability to find space and create attacking opportunities. As Kayo Sports’ Sam Hargreaves noted, the Hawks might ‘roll five or six players through’ the midfield, showcasing different variations throughout the game. But is this flexibility a strength or a sign of uncertainty?
Meanwhile, the battle for Hawthorn’s two vacant list spots is heating up. Ex-Roos backman Flynn Perez is the early frontrunner, turning heads with his ball use and long-range kicking. But Jack Riding isn’t far behind, showing glimpses of potential in defense. Who will secure the spot? It’s anyone’s guess.
Now, let’s talk Geelong. Their 17-point loss to Hawthorn (94-111) wasn’t the only story. Here’s the real question: Can Ollie Dempsey become the Cats’ midfield powerhouse? The 2024 Rising Star showcased his speed and physicality, but with Bailey Smith, Max Holmes, and Tanner Bruhn absent, is he truly ready for the engine room?
Another standout was 19-year-old Jay Polkinghorne, who provided a tall forward option alongside Shannon Neale. With Jeremy Cameron injured and Tyson Stengle absent, Polkinghorne’s three goals were a timely reminder of his potential. But is he consistent enough to lock down a spot?
Ollie Henry also made his case with three goals, aiming to reclaim his place in Chris Scott’s side after falling out of favor last year. But here’s the controversial take: Are the Cats spreading themselves too thin by experimenting with so many young players, or are they building a dynamic, versatile squad?
As we dissect these match simulations, one thing’s clear: the 2026 season is shaping up to be unpredictable. What’s your take? Are the Hawks’ ‘committee’ approach and the Cats’ youth focus bold strategies or risky gambles? Let us know in the comments—we’d love to hear your thoughts!
